In March 2018, Pinkston began dating lifestyle blogger Justine Garcia. During a joint appearance on The Freddie & Alyssa Show podcast that same year, the cute pair revealed that they actually first met through a group of mutual friends years earlier but kept things platonic until one fateful "friend date" — Garcia's words, not ours — changed it all. "We went out and got dinner and drinks and ... the hearts never left my eyes," Pinkston explained. He added, "This is the longest I've known someone and was friends with someone before I started dating. And the great thing, I would say, about that is that there were no surprises. I kind of knew who she was as a person already."
These two are also known to gush over one another on social media. "One year down. One hundred to go! Happy Anniversary my love," Garcia, who also founded the sarcoma cancer awareness foundation the Olivia Project, wrote on Instagram in March 2019. Weeks later, Pinkston shared, "As long as you'll have me, you'll never be alone, I promise. You are my heart, you are my everything. I love you. So. Much." Go ahead and let out an "aww" — we definitely did!
ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7r7XCpKCsr5mbwW%2BvzqZmam1jbYV1e9ahmK2dppq%2FbrTAqaeeppWZerW7jKuwmqZdpbavt9Ktpqdn
ncG1vNJzZmibmZfEb63MrGpnnJmctrWty6ianpmeqL2ir8SsZZynnWS7psPSZqypnJGpsnDDx5qrnq6Vp3qprc%2BpnKedlGLBsHnRspinZaCeu6y%2F06ilZmpmaYV0esetpKU%3D